Looking back over numerous conversations back and forth on the comments section of Balancing the Basin it appears there may be a major misunderstanding about what Save Our Lakes Now is suggesting concerning drought management. Our suggestion is to hold lake levels constant as long as release rates can be maintained at 3600cfs or higher. Once 3600cfs is reached, our suggestion is to continue 3600cfs for the duration of the drought to minimize the total impact on lake interests.
Looking more closely at the objections to this there seems to be an underlying argument from naysayers that this will only help a little in terms of minimum levels reached. What seems to be misunderstood is we are only asking for a little help. Following this strategy until the drought is over the drop in lake level should be less than 10'. While a drop of 10' is not desirable, it is not disastrous. Launching ramps are still useable, marina problems are minimal, recreation is still possible, and impact on property values is tolerable.
Again, we feel lake interests are not adequately consulted on drought measures. We are not asking to destroy downstream interests. We are simply suggesting a better compromise between the various options available. The primary challenge to this approach is it would impact power quotas more. We feel strongly that the value of fresh water saved and recreational dollars salvaged far outweigh the impact on power costs to the consumer. Power quotas need to be weighed against real costs to recreation and not just followed blindly.
Sunday, April 19, 2015
Wednesday, April 1, 2015
THIS COULD HAPPEN HERE
Jerry Clontz sent a copy of this article from Michael Reagan about what is happening to the water out West. One irony we note is the powers that be have not yet realized that release rates from the reservoirs have a major effect here. This could well be prophetic about the SRB unless we do a better job of balancing releases against rain fall.
California is running out of water. The Bible, in Matthew 5:45, says the rain falls on the just and the unjust and the same goes for the drought. According to Jay Famiglietti, a senior water scientist at NASA: “NASA data reveal that total water storage in California has been in steady decline since at least 2002, when satellite-based monitoring began, although groundwater depletion has been going on since the early 20th century.”
And last winter’s “rainy season” didn’t help much either. January was the driest since people started collecting raindrops in 1895. Famiglietti adds that all the water currently stored in the state — “snow, river, and reservoir water, water in soils and groundwater combined — was 34 million acre-feet below normal in 2014. That loss is nearly 1.5 times the capacity of Lake Mead, America's largest reservoir.”
Since farmers can’t depend on the clouds for crop moisture, they’ve increased groundwater pumping and as a result in the Central Valley land is literally sinking, in some areas by as much as a foot. You may be thinking that’s planning ahead; when it finally starts to rain, farmer Jones will have a lake. But that’s not how it works. And no one is predicting rain.
In his Los Angeles Times piece, Famiglietti wisely resists the temptation to blame the drought on global warming, which made him much more credible in my book. His first recommendation is to begin mandatory water rationing throughout the state. After that he loses me.
Famiglietti wants to add to the state’s bureaucracy by creating “regional groundwater sustainability agencies” that will adopt plans. Then he wants a task force to “brainstorm” long-term water management strategies.
Then we really part company. His final recommendation is: “Finally, the public must take ownership of this issue. This crisis belongs to all of us — not just to a handful of decision-makers.” This is completely wrong. California is a democracy and for the past 40 years elected officials have done zero planning for long-term drought and have not built a new dam or reservoir since 2000.
I’m certainly willing to do my part and ration my use of water until the rain comes again. But I have no intention of accepting responsibility for the inaction and inability to set priorities demonstrated by state water authorities and elected officials.
California is running out of water. The Bible, in Matthew 5:45, says the rain falls on the just and the unjust and the same goes for the drought. According to Jay Famiglietti, a senior water scientist at NASA: “NASA data reveal that total water storage in California has been in steady decline since at least 2002, when satellite-based monitoring began, although groundwater depletion has been going on since the early 20th century.”
And last winter’s “rainy season” didn’t help much either. January was the driest since people started collecting raindrops in 1895. Famiglietti adds that all the water currently stored in the state — “snow, river, and reservoir water, water in soils and groundwater combined — was 34 million acre-feet below normal in 2014. That loss is nearly 1.5 times the capacity of Lake Mead, America's largest reservoir.”
Since farmers can’t depend on the clouds for crop moisture, they’ve increased groundwater pumping and as a result in the Central Valley land is literally sinking, in some areas by as much as a foot. You may be thinking that’s planning ahead; when it finally starts to rain, farmer Jones will have a lake. But that’s not how it works. And no one is predicting rain.
In his Los Angeles Times piece, Famiglietti wisely resists the temptation to blame the drought on global warming, which made him much more credible in my book. His first recommendation is to begin mandatory water rationing throughout the state. After that he loses me.
Famiglietti wants to add to the state’s bureaucracy by creating “regional groundwater sustainability agencies” that will adopt plans. Then he wants a task force to “brainstorm” long-term water management strategies.
Then we really part company. His final recommendation is: “Finally, the public must take ownership of this issue. This crisis belongs to all of us — not just to a handful of decision-makers.” This is completely wrong. California is a democracy and for the past 40 years elected officials have done zero planning for long-term drought and have not built a new dam or reservoir since 2000.
I’m certainly willing to do my part and ration my use of water until the rain comes again. But I have no intention of accepting responsibility for the inaction and inability to set priorities demonstrated by state water authorities and elected officials.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)